Menu
Log in
Log in

Dispositive Motions

Friday, November 20, 2026 3:31 PM | Anonymous

Dispositive Motion in Arbitration

If the outcome of a dispositive motion involves thousands of dollars possibly lost to the arbitrator if the motion is granted, should the parties let the presiding arbitrator decide the motion? Should they select another arbitrator to decide that specific motion?

What are your thoughts? 


Comments

  • Friday, November 20, 2026 5:21 PM | Jack Levin
    I wonder why counsel or a party would ever select an arbitrator whose character was suspect in this way.
    Link  •  Reply
  • Friday, November 20, 2026 5:25 PM | Michael H. Diamant
    I have decided numerous dispositive motions either as a sole arbitrator or as panel chair or panel wing. In no case was potential loss of arbitrator compensation an issue. Further, dispositive motions often require an in-depth knowledge of the case facts and relevant documents. To have an additional arbitrator get up to speed would greatly enhance the costs to the parties and cause substantial delays.
    Link  •  Reply
  • Friday, November 20, 2026 5:32 PM | Julia E. Sullivan
    I believe in hourly rates. Early dispute resolution means lower costs for the parties and less work for the arbitrator. Seems like a win-win unless you assume the arbitrator is desperate enough for billable hours to compromise the one thing that is absolutely indispensable -- their integrity.
    Link  •  Reply
    • Saturday, November 21, 2026 11:44 AM | Steven V. Modica
      I agree with this sentiment 100%. Thanks for capturing what is most critical, that is, the integrity of the arbitrator.
      Link  •  Reply
  • Friday, November 20, 2026 5:34 PM | Steven Skulnik
    The applicable rules authorize the arbitral tribunal to summarily determine claims and defenses. They do not authorize the chair alone nor someone not even on the tribunal to make the decision. The notion that arbitrators' decisions in these matters (or any other procedural decisions that promote efficiency) are motivated by fees is ridiculous.
    Link  •  Reply
    • Friday, November 20, 2026 6:31 PM | Michael Seng
      I may be naive, but I can’t imagine an arbitrator being influenced on a dispositive motion ruling by fear of losing fees. Even if his or her goal was purely selfish, we all know that few of these cases go to formal hearing; seems even an unscrupulous person would not sacrifice his soul on the outside chance a hearing will be necessary.
      Link  •  Reply
  • Friday, November 20, 2026 9:19 PM | Tom Gibbons
    An arbitrator has a duty to minimize costs for the parties. To require a separate arbitrator to consider a dispositive motion would incur additional costs for the second arbitrator to get up to speed and would cause unnecessary delay. It is also highly unlikely any arbitrator would trade their professional reputation, our most valued asset, to tank a decision for a handful of billable hours. Parties are also well aware that the vast majority of these cases settle or are decided by dispositive motion and recognize (and accept) it is the arbitrator who they selected will consider these early issues.
    Link  •  
    Author
    Comment
     
  • Saturday, November 21, 2026 11:52 AM | Lesley Green
    I concur with others' comments. I am frankly surprised by this question. It would be unethical for an arbitrator to consider his/her fees in deciding a dispositive motion. I would assume the parties do not select an arbitrator whom they believe to be unethical. I would also question the empirical basis for this inquiry which appears to assume that dispositive motions are not granted in arbitration as often as they are in court. That has not been my experience.
    Link  •  Reply
  • Saturday, November 21, 2026 1:24 PM | Marc Elliott
    I 100% agree with the comments here. I can't imagine any arbitrator denying a dispositive motion because they'd be losing fees they'd otherwise earn if the case continued.
    Link  •  Reply
  • Sunday, November 22, 2026 12:40 PM | William Bankston
    The presiding arbitrator should have the dispositive motion decided by the panel. The motion should never be referred to another arbitrator. As an arbitrator for over 45 years, I find it offensive that anyone would suggest that a ruling would consider a loss of fees to the arbitrators.
    Link  •  Reply
  • Sunday, November 22, 2026 12:42 PM | Robert Alston
    I assume the Motion would go the Arb on the case, not a second. If Arb on case votes their pocketbook, they shouldn’t be serving.
    Link  •  Reply
Association for Conflict Resolution - Greater New York Chapter

© 2026 ACR-GNY

Contact Us

Email us at questions@acrgny.org

ACR-GNY's mission and programming are generously sponsored by:

ADR Notable: Dispute Resolution Management Made Easy
Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software